Dr. Umar Responds to Ed Lover, DJ Akademiks & MC Shan Defending Eminem, Disputing Claims of Em Not Being the Hip-Hop GOAT | WhatsOnRap

Dr. Umar Addresses Ed Lover, MC Shan, and DJ Akademiks in Defense of Eminem

Dr. Umar Sparks Controversy on Eminem's Status in Hip-Hop: Clashing Perspectives in the Industry Unfold
In a recent exchange of words within the hip-hop community, Dr. Umar found himself at the center of a debate regarding Eminem's place in the genre. As Ed Lover, MC Shan, and DJ Akademiks stepped up to defend Eminem against Umar's assertion that the rapper can't be considered one of the greatest due to his race, tensions escalated on social media.

Addressing Ed Lover and MC Shan on social media, Dr. Umar stood firm in his stance, stating, "I stand, unapologetically, in defense of Afrikan culture against co-optation, usurpation, and colonization by outsiders." He emphasized that while he may not be an expert on hip-hop, he is well-versed in the exploitation of Black culture by non-Afrikans. Despite the disagreement, Dr. Umar clarified that he never questioned Eminem's talent but resisted the idea of anointing him as the G.O.A.T.
Responding to Ed Lover's defense of Eminem, Dr. Umar criticized the colorblind rhetoric and questioned Lover's lack of vocal opposition when Eminem faced backlash for racist lyrics. Lover, in turn, defended the inclusivity of hip-hop, highlighting its diverse contributors from various ethnicities.

Turning his attention to MC Shan, Dr. Umar expressed disappointment in seeing respected icons rushing to the defense of a non-Afrikan without provocation. He disagreed with Shan's perspective on Eminem's ghetto origins and emphasized the failure to understand white privilege in America.

In the DJ Akademiks segment, Dr. Umar dismissed the comparison between rap and golf, asserting that the latter has a clearly defined championship criteria and isn't a cherished aspect of Afrikan culture. He called out Akademiks for what he perceived as allegiance to Eminem without considering the historical context of Black culture.

Ed Lover responded, defending the diverse roots of hip-hop and asserting that the music genre was never meant to belong to any one ethnicity. He pointed out the contributions of individuals like Rick Rubin and the Beastie Boys, emphasizing the rights of everyone to excel in hip-hop.

This clash of perspectives within the hip-hop community highlights ongoing debates about cultural ownership, racial dynamics, and the evolving nature of the genre. As the discussions continue, it remains to be seen whether a middle ground can be found or if the differing opinions will persist within the diverse landscape of hip-hop.

Follow us:  | Twitter Instagram |  Facebook